BOCK

General

Cellulite Treatment Can Soften Thigh Dimples. The Evidence That Any Device Erases Them Is Thin.

In the Prado Museum in Madrid hangs The Three Graces, painted by Peter Paul Rubens in the 1630s. Three nude women stand close together, and the soft dimples and folds of their thighs and hips are painted without any attempt to hide them. The word Rubenesque still describes a body drawn with that kind of generosity.

Patients bring me the opposite expectation. They point to the back of the thigh or the buttock and ask whether something can be injected or heated to make it smooth. Cellulite treatment (the dimpled, uneven look of skin over the thighs and buttocks) is one of the most requested cosmetic procedures, and the honest answer is that some options soften it, but none has been shown to erase it. The trials are small, mostly uncontrolled and short, and the injection options cost patients a great deal of bruising.


What is cellulite, and what are treatments trying to change?

Cellulite is dimpling of the skin over the thighs and buttocks. It is commonly attributed to fibrous bands that tether the skin to the deeper tissue while fat bulges between them. Treatments therefore take one of two routes. Some try to cut or dissolve the bands, as subcision and collagenase injections do. Others heat the tissue, as radiofrequency devices do, and hope to reshape the fat, the skin or both.

That difference matters for what a patient can expect. A treatment aimed at the bands targets one cause of the dimple. A treatment aimed at heat and fat targets another. No single study in this review compares them directly.


Do collagenase injections and subcision work, and which causes more side effects?

The best pooled data compare the two band-releasing methods, and what it measures most clearly is side effects. A 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Global Open pooled 14 studies covering 1,254 patients treated on the thighs and buttocks (Foppiani et al., 2024). Nine studies were of tissue subcision, in which a needle is used to release the bands under the skin, and five were of collagenase injection, which uses an enzyme to break down the collagen in the bands. In total, 465 patients received collagenase and 789 underwent subcision.

The authors concluded that both methods seem effective. The pooled figures they report, though, are about adverse events. Bruising occurred in 89% of collagenase patients (95% CI, 71% to 96%) and 99% of subcision patients (95% CI, 85% to 99%) (Foppiani et al., 2024). Pain requiring an analgesic was reported in 74% with collagenase and 60% with subcision. Induration (a firm, hard area under the skin) was about 7% in both. Skin discoloration was higher after collagenase, at 16% versus 7% after subcision.

In plain terms, bruising after either injection route is the rule rather than the exception. The two differ mostly in how they bother the patient afterwards.


Does radiofrequency improve cellulite?

Radiofrequency (RF) studies report improvement, but the two I reviewed are tiny and preliminary. A 2022 report in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery described 10 women with grade 2 and grade 3 cellulite of the thighs or buttocks (Peters, 2022). The treatment used a minimally invasive bipolar RF probe that heated tissue to predetermined internal temperature endpoints at several levels, followed by suction of the coagulated fat through a small cannula. At six months, photographs of 70 body areas were randomised and scored by five blinded evaluators on the Photonumeric Cellulite Severity Scale. The author reported statistically significant improvement in all body area comparisons and described the magnitude as large. There was no control group.

A 2025 study in the Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology tested a different, non-invasive RF device on the thighs of eight people (Santos et al., 2025). After eight sessions given every 72 to 96 hours, thigh circumference fell by 3% (p < 0.05), the subcutaneous fat layer measured on ultrasound fell by 20% (p < 0.01), and skin echogenicity, which the authors use as a marker of skin organisation and collagen content, rose by 6% (p < 0.05). All participants reported satisfaction and no adverse events were reported. The authors are affiliated with the company named in the study as the device's manufacturer.

The two studies used different devices, and one involves a small procedure with a cannula while the other does not. They point in the same direction, but they cannot be pooled or ranked.


What are the limits of this evidence?

Some will say that cellulite is a cosmetic issue, so a small study with a good photograph is enough. That is partly fair. A treatment with a low risk of serious harm does not need the evidence of a cancer drug. But patients are paying for a specific promise, a smoother surface, and the studies so far cannot say how much smoother, for how long, or for which patient.

The meta-analysis pooled studies of varying design and reported side effects rather than a pooled measure of improvement (Foppiani et al., 2024). The RF reports had 10 and 8 participants, no comparison group, and follow-up of six months at most (Peters, 2022; Santos et al., 2025). None of the three compared a collagenase or subcision treatment with an RF treatment, so no one can say which route is better for a given patient.


What should you ask before treating cellulite?

Ask what the treatment is targeting and what the evidence shows for that device or technique. A dimple pulled down by bands, a dimple with fat bulging above it and a thigh with loose skin are different problems, and a plan should say which one is being treated. Ask what bruising to expect and for how long, because the pooled data suggest it is nearly universal after injection-based options. Ask how the clinic will judge the result, using photographs under the same lighting and angle before and after, rather than a verbal impression.


The Clinical Bottom Line

Cellulite treatment is best framed as softening, not erasing. Collagenase and subcision seem effective in the pooled review, and both come with frequent bruising. RF-based approaches show improvement in small, uncontrolled studies, so the case for any one device rests on thin ground.

A patient who wants a clear, durable change in the thigh surface should hear that these are modest tools with limited data. A patient who wants a gentle improvement and accepts some downtime has a more realistic target. Either way, expectations set before treatment matter as much as the device chosen.

Rubens painted the dimple as part of the body. Medicine can soften it for patients who want that, but it should not pretend the body was ever wrong.

For clinical assessments and consultation in Seoul: itsdrbock.com


References

Foppiani, J. A., Raska, O., Galinaud, C., Stearns, S., Hernandez Alvarez, A., Taritsa, I. C., Schuster, K. A., Ho, O. A., TerKonda, S., Lee, B. T., & Lin, S. J. (2024). Comparing collagenase and tissue subcision for cellulite treatment of the buttock and thigh regions: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Global Open, 12(6), Article e5857. https://doi.org/10.1097/GOX.0000000000005857

Peters, M. H. (2022). Use of minimally invasive radiofrequency-assisted lipolysis as a novel treatment of grade 2 and grade 3 cellulite. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 150(4), 809–813. https://doi.org/10.1097/PRS.0000000000009567

Rubens, P. P. (c. 1635). The three graces [Oil painting]. Museo del Prado, Madrid, Spain.

Santos, A. F., Fernández, A. I., Fernández, L. S., Zapico, L. H., & Freitag, S. V. (2025). Effectiveness of body remodeling and cellulite appearance improvement treatments in the thighs using Symmed radiofrequency device. Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology, 24(1), Article e16796. https://doi.org/10.1111/jocd.16796

More From the Blog